Atenveldt Submissions (excerpted from the S.C.A. College of Arms' Letters of Acceptance and Return)
- Registrations and Returns,November 2020
- Registrations and Returns,October 2020
- Registrations and No Returns,September 2020
- Registrations and No Returns,August 2020
- Registrations and Pends,July 2020
- Registrations and Returns,June 2020
- Registrations and No Returns,May 2020
- Registrations and Returns,April 2020
- Registrations and Returns,March 2020
- Registrations and Returns, February 2020
- Registrations and No Returns, January 2020
- Registrations and Returns,December 2019
- Registrations and Returns,November 2019
- Registrations and Returns,October 2019
- Registrations and Returns,September 2019
- Registrations and Returns,August 2019
- Registrations and Returns,July 2019
- Registrations and Returns,June 2019
- Registrations and Returns,May 2019
- Registrations and Returns,April` 2019
- Registrations and Returns,March 2019
- Registrations and Returns,February 2019
- Registrations and Returns,January 2019
- Registrations and Returns,December 2018
- Registrations and Returns,November 2018
- Registrations and Returns,October 2018
- Registrations and Returns,September 2018
- Registrations and Returns,August 2018
- Registrations and Returns,July 2018
- Registrations and Returns,June 2018
- Registrations and No Returns,May 2018
- Registrations and Returns,April 2018
- Registrations and Returns,March 2018
- Registrations and Returns,February 2018
- Registrations and Returns,January 2018
- Registrations and Returns,December 2017
- Registrations and Returns,November 2017
- Registrations and No Returns,October 2017
- No Registrations and No Returns,September 2017
- Registrations and No Returns,August 2017
- Registrations and Returns,July 2017
- Registrations and Returns,June 2017
- Registrations and Returns,April 2017
- Registrations and Returns,March 2017
- Registrations and Returns,January 2017
- Registrations and Returns,December 2016
- Registrations and Returns,November 2016
- Registrations and Returns,October 2016
- Registrations and Returns,August 2016
- Registrations and Returns,July 2016
- Registrations and Returns,June 2016
- Registrations and Returns,May 2016
- Registrations and Returns,April 2016
- Registrations and Returns,March 2016
- Registrations and Returns,February 2016
- Registrations and Returns,January 2016
- Registrations and Returns,December 2015
- Registrations and Returns,November 2015
- Registrations and Returns,October 2015
- Registrations and Returns,September 2015
- Registrations and Returns,August 2015
- Registrations and Returns,July 2015
- Registrations and Returns,June 2015
- Registrations and Returns,May 2015
- Registrations and Returns,April 2015
- Registrations and Returns,March 2015
- Registrations and Returns,February 2015
- Registrations and Returns,December 2014
- Registrations and Returns,Novembery 2014
- Registrations and Returns,October 2014
- Registrations and Returns,September 2014
- Registrations and Returns,August 2014
- Registrations and Returns,July 2014
- Registrations and Returns,June 2014
- Registrations and Returns,May 2014
- Registrations and No Returns,April 2014
- Registrations and Returns,March 2014
- Registrations and Returns,February 2014
- Registrations and Returns,January 2014
- Registrations and No Returns,December 2013
- Registrations and Returns,November 2013
- Registrations and Returns,October 2013
- Registrations and No Returns,September 2013
- Registrations and Returns,August 2013
- Registrations and Returns,July 2013
- Registrations and Returns,June 2013
- Registrations and No Returns,May 2013
- Registrations and Returns,April 2013
- Registrations and Returns,March 2013
- Registrations and No Returns,February 2013
- Registrations and Returns,January 2013
- Registrations and Returns,December 2012
- Registrations and Returns,November 2012
- Registrations and No Returns,October 2012
- Registrations and Returns,September 2012
- Registrations and Returns,August 2012
- Registrations and Returns,July 2012
- Registrations and Returns,June 2012
- Registrations and Returns,May 2012
- Registrations and Returns,April 2012
- Registrations and Returns,March 2012
- Registrations and Returns,February 2012
- Registrations and Returns,January 2012
- Registrations and Returns,December 2011
- Registrations and Returns,November 2011
- Registrations and No Returns,October 2011
- Registrations and Returns,September 2011
- Registrations and Returns,August 2011
- Registrations and Returns,July 2011
- Registrations and Returns,June 2011
- Registrations and No Returns,May 2011
- Registrations and No Returns,April 2011
- Registrations and Returns,March 2011
- Registrations and Returns,February 2011
- Registrations and Returns,January 2011
- Registrations and Returns,December 2010
- Registrations and No Returns,November 2010
- Registrations and No Returns,October 2010
- Registrations and Returns, September 2010
- Registrations and Returns, August 2010
- Registrations and Returns, July 2010
- Registrations and Returns, June 2010
- Registrations and Returns, May 2010
- Registrations and Returns, April 2010
- Registrations and Returns, March 2010
- Registrations and Returns, February 2010
- Registrations and Returns, January 2010
- Registrations and Returns, December 2009
- Registrations and No Returns, November 2009
- Registrations and Returns, October 2009
- Registrations and Returns, September 2009
- Registrations and Returns, August 2009
- Registrations and Returns, July 2009
- Registrations and Returns, June 2009
- Registrations and Returns, May 2009
- Registrations and Returns, April 2009
- Registrations and Returns, March 2009
- Registrations and Returns, February 2009
- Registrations and Returns, January 2009
- Registrations and Returns, December 2008
- Registrations and Returns, November 2008
- Registrations and Returns, October 2008
- Registrations and Returns, September 2008
- Registrations and Returns, August 2008
- Registrations and Returns, July 2008
- Registrations and Returns, June 2008
- Registrations and Returns, May 2008
- Registrations and Returns, April 2008
- Registrations and No Returns, March 2008
- Registrations and No Returns, February 2008
- Registrations and Returns, January 2008
- Registrations and Returns, November 2007
- Registrations and Returns, October 2007
- Registrations and Returns, September 2007
- Registrations and Returns, August 2007
- Registrations and Returns, July 2007
- Registrations and Returns, June 2007
- Registrations and Returns, May 2007
- Registrations and NO Returns, April 2007
- Registrations and Returns, March 2007
- Registrations and Returns, February 2007
- Registrations and Returns, January 2007
- Registrations and Returns, December 2006
- Registrations and NO Returns, November 2006
- Registrations and Returns, October 2006
- Registrations and Returns, September 2006
- Registrations and Returns, August 2006
- Registrations and Returns, July 2006
- Registrations and Returns, June 2006
- Registrations and Returns, May 2006
- Registrations and Returns, March 2006
- Registrations and Returns, February 2006
- Registrations and Returns, January 2006
- Registrations and Returns, November 2005
- Registrations and Returns, October 2005
- Registrations and Returns, September 2005
- Registrations and Returns, August 2005
- Registrations and Returns, July 2005
- Registrations and NO Returns, June 2005
- Registrations and Returns, May 2005
- Registrations and Returns, April 2005
- Registrations and Returns, March 2005
- Registrations and Returns, February 2005
- Registrations and Returns, January 2005
- Registrations and Returns, December 2004
- Registrations and Returns, November 2004
- NO Registrations and NO Returns, October 2004
- Registrations and Returns, September 2004
- Registrations and Returns, August 2004
- Registrations and Returns, July 2004
- Registrations and Returns, June 2004
- Registrations and Returns, May 2004
- Registrations and Returns, April 2004
- NO Registrations and NO Returns, March 2004
- Registrations and Returns, February 2004
- Registrations and Returns, January 2004
- Registrations and Returns, December 2003
- Registrations and Returns, November 2003
- Registrations and Returns, October 2003
- NO Registrations and NO Returns, September 2003
- Registrations and Returns, August 2003
- Registrations and Returns, July 2003
- Registrations and Returns, June 2003
- Registrations and Returns, May 2003
- Registrations and Returns, April 2003
- NO Registrations and NO Returns, March 2003
- Registrations and Returns, February 2003
- Registrations and Returns, January 2003
- Registrations and Returns, December 2002
- Registrations and Returns, November 2002
- Registrations and Returns, October 2002
- Registrations and Returns, September 2002
- Registrations and Returns, August 2002
- Registrations and Returns, July 2002
- Registrations and Returns, June 2002
- NO Registrations and NO Returns, May 2002
- Registrations and Returns, April 2002
- Registrations and Returns, March 2002
- Registrations and Returns, February 2002
- Registrations and Returns, January 2002
- Registrations and Returns, December 2001
- Registrations and NO Returns!, November 2001
- Registrations and NO Returns!, October 2001
- Registrations and Returns, September 2001
- Registrations and Returns, August 2001
- Registrations and Returns, July 2001
- Registrations and Returns, June 2001
- Registrations and NO Returns!, May 2001
- Registrations and Returns, April 2001
- Registrations and Returns, March 2001
- Registrations and Returns, February 2001
- Registrations and Returns, December 2000
- Registrations and Returns, November 2000
- Registrations and Returns, October 2000
- Registrations and Returns, August 2000
- Registrations and Returns, July 2000
- Registrations and Returns, June 2000
The
following submissions were registered by the S.C.A. College of Arms,
June 2015:
Agnes
Carrick. Name.
- Agnes
was documented in the Letter of Intent as a 12th century English
given name and Carrick to 1569. In commentary, Ogress
documented Agnes to Scotland in Aryanhwy merch Catmael's
"Index of Scots Names in Dictionary of the Older Scottish
Tongue"
(http://www.ellipsis.cx/~liana/names/scots/dost/agnes.html), dated
between 1530 and 1597.
Nice 16th century Scots name! -
Aillenn
inghean Chonaill. Name.
Submitted as Aileann
inghean Conall,
the spelling Aileann is an undated header form found in OC&M.
The standard Middle Irish Gaelic form is Aillenn.
We have changed the given name to the period form. The father's
name, Conall, needs to be in the genitive (possessive) form
and lenited: inghean Chonaill. We note that this name
mixes a Middle Irish Gaelic given name and Early Modern Irish Gaelic
byname. A wholly Middle Irish form of this name, appropriate for the
10th century, is Aillenn ingen Chonaill.
If the submitter prefers this form, she can submit a request for
reconsideration. -
Ailric Atte
Grange. Name and device. Per pale embattled sable and argent,
a hare and a squirrel combattant counterchanged.
The
submitter requested authenticity for an unspecified place and time.
The given name wasn't found later than 1212, and the byname was
dated to 1296. The capitalization of the preposition Atte is
reasonable, but atypical. For example, the Middle English Dictionary
includes examples such as Gilberto Atte Chapell, dated to
1385. Given the gap of over 80 years between the given name and
byname this name may be authentic for 13th century England, but we
do not know for sure. -
al-Haddad
ibn `Abd al-Jabbar. Name and device. Sable, a bend sinister
embattled between a mouse rampant contourny and an increscent Or.
Submitted as Al Haddad IBN ABD AL JaBBar, the name
appeared in the Letter of Intent as al-Haddad ibn
`Abd al-Jabb{a-}r. A consistent
transliteration scheme must be used consistently throughout a name.
Therefore, we have changed the name to al-Haddad ibn `Abd
al-Jabbar in order to register this name,
as this is the closest to what was submitted. We note that
al-{H.}add{a-}d ibn
`Abd al-Jabb{a-}r is also
registerable. Submissions heralds are reminded to summarize all
changes made to a name. As seen in this submission, a bend
embattled is embattled only on the upper edge. -
Alkibiades
Attikou Argeios. Name and device. Vert, a tortoise rampant
argent and in chief three goblets Or each entwined with a serpent
erect contourny argent.
The submitter requested authenticity
for classical Greece, and requested a name meaning "Alkibades,
son of Attikos, of Argos". This name meets the request for
authenticity and has the desired meaning. -
Alpin Hunter. Name.
-
Aoibhenn
inghean Ui Mhaille. Name.
Submitted as Aoibhenn inghean
Ui Maille, Aldyrne noted in commentary that
the given name Aoibhenn is a partially updated 17th century
form of a 10th-11th century name. Therefore, this name is a
plausible late period form. However, we have changed the byname to
Ui Mhaille in order to add the necessary
lenition. The submitter may wish to know that a wholly Middle
Irish Gaelic form of this name, appropriate for c.900-c.1200, is
Aibinn ingen Ui Maille. -
Archibald
Henderson. Name.
Nice 16th century Scots name! -
Bergdís Berbeinn. Name.
-
Beth
of Granite Mountain. Name and device. Argent, in fess a
natural dolphin haurient azure and a sheaf of arrows gules, a chief
counter-ermine.
Beth is the submitter's legal
given name. It is also an attested English and Dutch given name,
dated to the 16th century, so the submitter need not rely on the
legal name allowance. Granite Mountain is the registered
name of an SCA branch. Please advise the submitter to draw fewer
and larger ermine spots. -
Cameron of Ered Sûl. Holding
name and device (see RETURNS for name). Azure, a lion sejant
contourny argent maintaining a shepherd's crook Or between three
triskeles argent.
-
Submitted
under the name Cameron MacLaren.
-
Cathal Finn
Ó Briain. Badge. Argent semy of lozenges, a bordure gules.
Nice badge! -
Caylye
Gaspur. Name and device. Azure, a wolf-headed beaver rampant
Or, a bordure Or semy of triskelions of spirals gules.
There
is a step from period practice for the use of triskelions of
spirals. -
Ceara
inghean Chárthaigh. Device. Argent, a schnecke issuant from
base purpure and in chief a lizard tergiant fesswise vert.
There
is a step from period practice for the use of a schnecke with
another charge. -
Decima Aspenewell. Name
and device. Argent, a tree
blasted and eradicated purpure and a bordure purpure semy of
cogwheels argent.
-
Dominic de
la Mer. Badge. (Fieldless) A fox sejant gardant queue-forchy
proper within and conjoined to an annulet vert.
-
Dubhchobhlaigh
inghean Eoin uí Ealaighthe. Household name House of Green
Cart.
This follows the pattern of a house named after a
person. Green is an English given name dated to 1644, and
Cart is an English byname dated to 1596 in the FamilySearch
Historical Records. The submitter may wish to know that House
of the Green Cart would also be
registerable, using the pattern of color + heraldic charge. -
Emma Mordeboice. Name and
device. Argent, a butterfly purpure and in chief three seeblätter
vert.
-
Enia
al-Andalusiyya. Name.
The byname
al-Andalusiyya
is a feminized form of a byname documented in the Letter of Intent
using Juliana de Luna's article "Andalusian Names: Arabs in
Spain"
(http://www.s-gabriel.org/names/juliana/andalusia/#Locative). The
names in this article date to c.700 to c.1200, so are not temporally
compatible with the 1539 Spanish given name under Appendix C of SENA
as documented in the Letter of Intent. However, the byname is
found in the name of Ahmad
ibn Qasim ibn Ahmad ibn al-faqih Qasim ibn al-shaykh al-Hajari
al-Andalusi, a
translator from the 16th to early 17th centuries, documented in
Gerard Wiegers, "A life between Europe and the Maghrib",
in The Middle East and
Europe: Encounters and Exchanges,
Geert Jan van Gelder and Ed de Moor, editors
(https://books.google.ca/books?id=YTUavFMto28C). The
16th-17th century instance is compatible with the late period Enia,
so we can register this name. The combination of Spanish and
Arabic is an acceptable lingual mix under Appendix C of SENA. -
Eoin the Steward. Device.
Argent, on a hurt a cross couped argent, a base sable.
-
Eric
Edgarson. Name change from Otto Christoph von Frankenau.
The
submitter's previous name, Otto Christoph von Frankenau, is
retained as an alternate name. -
Friedrich
Swartzen Hut. Name
change from Godfrey of Argyle (see RETURNS for device).
The
submitter's previous name, Godfrey
of Argyle, is
released. -
Gregory von
Dargun. Name.
Gregory is the submitter's legal
given name. The Letter of Intent also documented it to Prussia in
the late 16th century, so the submitter need not rely on the legal
name allowance. -
Hreiðarr
Eiríksson. Name.
Submitted as Hreiðarr Eiríkrson,
the Letter of Intent correctly noted that the patronym should be
Eiríksson. We have made this change in
order to register this name. -
Jaku'an
Kakujo. Badge. Sable, in pale an increscent and a decrescent
conjoined in fess, and the letter V, all within six billets in
annulo argent.
There is a step from period practice for the
use of charges in annulo not being in their default palewise
orientation. -
Keane
Unnarson of Gyldenholt. Name and device. Per fess sable and
azure, on a fess embowed argent a sea-serpent ondoyant gules.
Submitted as Keane Unnrson of
Gyldenholt, the correct patronym is Unnarson.
We have made this change in order to register this name. Keane
is the submitter's legal given name. Gyldenholt is the
registered name of an SCA branch. -
Malise
MacClure. Name.
Precedent states: Submitted as Malise
Lauird, the cited documentation does not support Malise
as a period spelling. Black, The Surnames of Scotland, cites
a Malise Bane in 1320. An examination of the source from
which this name was drawn, Cartularium Comitatus de Levenax
p.p. 47-48, shows that it is Black's (modern) translation of a name
that appears in Latin as a part of the full name Gillemore filio
Malisei dicti Bane. It is highly likely that this name is
a Latin representation of a Gaelic name and not an indication of an
Anglicized or Norman spelling. Therefore, this precedent still
applies: Submitted as Malise der Totschläger, the given name,
Malise, was documented from Withycombe, The Oxford Dictionary of
English Christian Names, as an Anglicization of the Gaelic name Mael
Iosa. Withycombe is not a reliable source for non-English names or
for anglicizations of Gaelic names. However, Black, The Surnames of
Scotland s.n. Malise, has Malis or Malisius in 1190 and 1210. The
name is also listed in Reaney and Wilson, A Dictionary of English
Surnames around the same time. We have changed the name to Malis der
Totschläger to match the documentation." [Loar 09/2005,
Atenveldt-A] We have changed the name to Malis
Lauird in order to register it. In commentary, Ogress
documented Malise as an English surname in the FamilySearch
Historical Records, so it can be registered as a late period given
name. Therefore, we are able to register this name in the submitted
spelling. -
Marina
Sparling. Name.
Nice 16th century English name!
Mariona Galloway. Name and
device. Sable, a talbot passant and on a chief Or an ear of wheat
fesswise sable. Nice 16th century English name!
- Matne
Dona. Name and device. Per bend sinister argent and vert, a
four-leaved clover and a skull facing sinister counterchanged.
-
Meadhbh
Edwin. Name and device. Per pale argent and vert, a sprig of
three holly leaves counterchanged fructed gules.
Submitted
as Meadhbh inghean Edwin, the byname
combines the Gaelic inghean and the English Edwin in
the same name phrase, a violation of PN1B1 of SENA, which states
that, "A registerable name phrase must follow the rules of
grammar and structure for a single time and place. It may not mix
languages unless that mixing of languages within a name phrase is
attested as a period practice." Therefore, we have dropped
inghean in order to register this name. The submitter may
wish to know that an English or Latinized English patronym such as
filia Edwini, Edwins, or Edwinsdoghter would
also be registerable. If she prefers one of these forms, she may
submit a request for reconsideration. This name combines a Gaelic
given name and English byname. This is an acceptable lingual mix
under Appendix C of SENA. -
Pero of
Windale. Holding name
and device (see PENDS for name). Argent, a brunette Franciscan monk
with arms outstretched robed proper and on a chief gules three Latin
crosses argent.
A precedent
from 2008 states: In registering the arms of the College of Sankt
Vladimir in October 2001 Laurel wrote: The device blazon appears
at first glance to refer to an argent angel on an argent field.
However, given the tinctures of the hair, wings and garb of the
angel, there is no argent portion of the angel which rests directly
on the field. Thus this has no more of a contrast problem than there
is in the arms Argent,
a cross argent fimbriated azure. The
same is true in this case: while Caucasian proper is equivalent to
argent, and thus generally not registerable on an argent field, in
this case no portion of the maiden's skin is touching the field. In
April 1993 (v. Rosamond of Lancashire) it was ruled "a design
that depends on artistic details (long flowing hair, style of dress)
to achieve acceptable contrast is fatally flawed". That
precedent referred to a maiden argent; Laurel noted at the time
"this would be acceptable if the maiden were entirely gules
-- indeed, if the skin were proper
I'd be willing to meet the submitter halfway -- but I can't permit
argent
on argent,
when only artistic license makes the figure visible." At this
time we are ruling that in the case of humans proper relying on the
hair and clothing to prevent a contrast problem is acceptable. If
you have to specify the hair style or style of clothing to guarantee
identifiability of the charge, then a contrast problem will exist.
If you simply say "crined and vested", and the result is
little or no skin touching the field, then a contrast problem
doesn't exist (assuming the human can still be identified). This
applies only to humans proper, not humans argent.[Jose Leodefrediz,
03/2008, A-Meridies] We have here a similar situation, as
Caucasian proper is equivalent to argent, and thus this device is
registerable. We are omitting the wooden bowl and cup from the
blazon as they are artistic details. Submitted under the name
Pero Tercero. -
Raza-Skúli.
Name.
Submitted as Skúli Raza, Raza-
is documented as a pre-pended byname, which comes before the given
name. We have changed the order to Raza-Skúli
in order to match the documentation. Commenters questioned
whether the byname Raza- ("arse") is offensive,
citing the return of Ávangr Bakrauf: Commenters were nearly
unanimous in stating that this name should be returned for
offensiveness due to the meaning of the byname ("asshole"
or "buttocks/anus"). SENA PN5A states that, "Similarly,
offense is not dependent on clarity. A foreign language name that
has an offensive meaning may be considered offensive, even if many
English-speaking listeners would not understand the term without
explanation". This notion is discussed more fully in an earlier
precedent: Some commenters argued that, because the name was in a
language that few SCA members understand, the sexual reference would
go unnoticed and hence the name would not be offensive. This
argument carries some weight. However, the rule does not make
exceptions for "offensive terms in the SCA lingua anglica".
We apply the same rules to non-English languages for documentation,
construction, and grammar; we must, therefore, apply the same
standards in matters of offensive. The rule doesn't say that the
Society has to understand it, but strongly suggests that the very
nature of the name is what makes it offensive, and once the
translation is made known, the name itself would be inherently
offensive to a large segment of the Society. Given this, we are
forced to return this name. [Finnr beytill, 01/2006] This name,
unfortunately, meets this standard and must be returned. Those
present at the Pelican decision meeting did not think that Raza-
is offensive, noting that "arse" does not have the same
connotation as the returned "anus" or "asshole".
Therefore, we are able to register this name. -
Roan
Feóirling. Name and badge. Azure, a sea-lion argent and
issuant from chief a demi-sun argent eclipsed sable.
This
name combines an English given name and Irish Gaelic byname. This is
an acceptable lingual mix under Appendix C of SENA. -
Shannon inghean uí Bhríain.
Device. Argent, on a bend embowed vert, a triquetra between
two four-leafed clovers slipped all palewise Or.
-
Shannon
inghean uí Bhríain. Badge. Argent, on a bend embowed vert,
a four-leafed clover slipped palewise Or.
-
Terra
of Burleigh. Name and device. Azure, a frog sustaining in
chief a drop spindle fesswise argent, a chief doubly-enarched Or.
Terra is the submitter's legal given
name. There is a step from period practice for the use of a chief
doubly-enarched. Please advise the submitter to draw the spindle
bigger and so that it doesn't touch the chief. -
Theodora
Akropolitissa. Name.
Submitted as Theodora Akropolitina,
the correct feminized form of the byname is Akropolitissa.
We have made this change in order to register this name. -
Thomas Ward of
Lancastreschire. Name and device. Per pale sable and gules, a
wolf rampant contourny and a skull, on a chief argent a sword gules.
-
Þorbi{o,}rn
Bjarnylr. Name and
device. Quarterly
sable and Or, a bear's head erased contourny between in bend two
escarbuncles argent.
-
Tobias
Wade. Name (see RETURNS for device).
Nice 12th century
English name! -
Tristan
Heley. Name and device. Or, three suns in pale gules between
a pair of flaunches sable, each charged with a six-petaled rose
argent.
The submitter requested authenticity for an Irish
name. However, Tristan is a French given name and the byname
is found in English and Anglicized Irish. This is an acceptable
lingual mix under Appendix C of SENA, but does not meet the
submitter's request for an authentic Irish name. -
William Devlin. Name.
-
The following were returned
for further work, June 2015:
Cameron
MacLaren. Name. Cameron was documented as the
submitter's legal middle name. Modernly, it is a surname and given
name by type. Documentation of Cameron as a Scots surname in
period was included in the Letter of Intent; however, we only allow
the surname as given name pattern for late period England. During the
Pelican decision meeting, Ogress also documented Cameron as an
English surname in the FamilySearch Historical Records, so it can be
used as a given name without relying on the legal name
allowance. Unfortunately, this name conflicts with the registered
Catherine MacLaren. Under certain pronunciations, only one
syllable has changed: Cath- versus Cam-. PN3C2 of SENA
states: Two names are also substantially different if a syllable is
substantially changed in sound and appearance. This means that the
vowel and the consonant (or group of consonants) on one side of the
vowel is different between the two names. In either case, the change
in spelling (including addition or removal of letters) must affect at
least two letters in that syllable to be substantial. In this
case, although the consonant on one side of the vowel has changed,
the vowel has not. Therefore, this name is not substantially
different and must be returned. His device is registered under the
holding name Cameron of Ered Sûl.
Enia
al-Andalusiyya. Device. Per fess embattled azure and argent, a
crossbow inverted and a dumbek counterchanged. This
device is returned for redraw, for violating SENA A2C2 which states
"Elements must be drawn to be identifiable." Here the
dumbek is too narrow in the lower section and resembles a thistle
head.
- Friedrich
Swartzen Hut. Device change. Lozengy bendwise azure and
argent, a hat sable.
This device is returned for not
being reliably blazonable, a violation of SENA A1C which requires
that the submitted emblazon must be reproducible by a competent
heraldic artist, with only normal heraldic variation, from the
written blazon. Because hats have always shown a huge variety of
shapes and size, we cannot define a "generic" standard
hat. All registerable hats would need to be clearly defined so as to
be reproducible from the blazon. Here the form of hat used was not
documented to period. -
Garth
MacPhail. Device. Per
chevron sable and gules, a fist sustaining a quill pen, on a chief
argent the words "MANU FORTICUM VERBA" in Roman capitals.
This
device is returned for redraw, for violating SENA A2C2 which states
"Elements must be drawn to be identifiable." Here some
commenters had trouble identifying the quill pen, confusing it with
a leaf. This could possibly be solved by adding some internal
detailing. Additionally, no evidence was provided that the text
matches a period hand. The submitter may want to know that a not
very classical Latin for the meaning they intend would be "MANU
FORTI CUM VERBIS". On the other hand, if he wants something
that would be more likely to appear in classical or literate
medieval Latin, it would more likely be "CUM MANU FORTI
VERBISQUE". -
Geneviève
de Lironcourt. Badge.
Sable, in saltire a stalk of celery and a carrot slipped, in chief
an onion argent.
This
device is returned for redraw, for violating SENA A2C2 which states
"Elements must be drawn to be identifiable." Here,
commenters had trouble identifying the celery and, to some extent,
the onion. It is also returned for blurring the distinction
between the primary and secondary charge groups. As depicted, the
onion is neither clearly a primary nor a secondary charge. This
could likely be solved by drawing the onion smaller so it is clearly
a secondary charge. -
Genta
Ishimash<ū
of the North. Name.
This name is returned for a lack of
documentation for the byname of the North. No examples of
locative bynames from which such a lingua Anglica form could be
constructed were found in Japan in our period. We are also
returning this name because the construction of Ishimash<ū
was not documented. In correspondence after the Pelican decision
meeting, Solveig Throndardottir noted that modifiers like Ishi
("rock") are not generally stacked onto compound modifiers
such as Mash<ū-dake,
the name of a mountain in Hokkaido, and Ishimash<ū<-
lacks the typical ending used in toponymic family names. In
addition, she suspects that Mash<ū
is an Ainu name, whereas Ishi is the native Japanese reading.
Therefore, Ishimash<ū
appears to combine two languages in the same name phrase, a
violation of PN1B1 of SENA. The submitter may wish to know that
there is a Japanese surname and feminine name from c.1600, Kita
("North"), found in NCMJ (revised edition). It can also be
glossed as "rice paddy". Therefore a name such as Kita
Genta followed by a suitable nanori is plausible. -
Michigane
Jirou of the North. Name.
This name is returned for a lack
of documentation for the byname of the North. No examples of
locative bynames from which such a lingua Anglica form could be
constructed were found in Japan in our period. The submitter may
wish to know that there is a Japanese surname and feminine name from
c.1600, Kita ("North"), found in NCMJ (revised
edition). It can also be glossed as "rice paddy".
Therefore a name such as Kita Jirou Michigane is plausible,
using the pattern family name + yobina + nanori. -
Tobias
Wade. Device. Gyronny
gules and Or, a fleur-de-lys azure.
This
device conflicts with the device of Elwyn of Snow Hill: Per
chevron azure, ermined argent, and argent, in base a fleur-de-lis
azure. The position of
the fleur-de-lys in Elwyn's device is forced and thus there is only
one DC for changing the field.
|